In the News

Amazon’s unsatisfying response prompted yet another inquiry in November. Spearheaded by Markey, this effort was joined by seven other lawmakers including Congressman Jimmy Gomez, a California Democrat. “We haven’t received much information and it seems like [for] somebody who’s very confident of their product it’s surprising that they won’t answer those questions,” Gomez told Gizmodo. Since this second letter was sent, yet another study indicated the presence of bias in Rekognition. Amazon contends that neither set of researchers followed the company’s guidelines for the software, but reporting by Gizmodo found that Rekognition’s only known law enforcement client — the Washington County Sheriff’s Office in Oregon — does not follow those suggested guidelines in its use of the software either. Representative Gomez said his staff asked Amazon if the company performs audits to make sure their clients are using the software as directed: “They said, ‘we have to get back to you.’” It’s possible there are other law enforcement clients besides the WCSO, but Amazon refuses to divulge them to reporters or lawmakers. “They haven’t given us the list of their clients,” Gomez told Gizmodo. He referenced reporting by the Daily Beast that indicated Amazon had been actively pitching Immigrations and Customs Enforcement on using Rekogntion, something he called “a big concern to the Latino community as a whole as well other pro-immigrant advocates.”

Full Article